Tuesday, November 23, 2010

HEA Members Forum Update

Last Chance to Comment on the New HEA Rate Plan
The new HEA rate plan was filed with the Regulatory Commission of Alaska on November 2, 2010. It is undergoing a 45-day review by RCA staff. At the end if this period (around December 17) staff will present recommendations to Commissioners and a docket will be open for further investigation. This will likely include a 20-day public review process. Watch for notice of this if you have concerns or suggestions about the proposed rate plan that you would like to bring before the RCA.

Weigh in on New Energy Efficiency Standards
The RCA is considering adoption of new amendments to the Public Utilities Regulatory Policies Act which are intended to encourage energy efficiency, among other things. As might be expected, the RCA staff suggests against adopting the federal standards but does propose some modest increase in state regulatory support for energy efficiency. You have until December 9 to submit comments. See the attached summary for more information and go to the source at http://rca.alaska.gov/RCAWeb/Dockets/DocketDetails.aspx?id=ccbcfb40-5010-41c7-af3d-d2e42b57241d.




Independent Light -- Not the Brightest Bulb
Through it’s shadow corporation, the Alaska Electric and Energy Cooperative, Inc., HEA approved spending another $4.5 million on equipment and design engineering services for the Nikiski facility and old Soldotna 1 site. Most of this, $3.3 million, went to the latter. For the most part people see the logic in spending money to improve efficiency of the Nikiski plant. But to many, in a situation where the natural gas supply is questionable, spending millions on new stand-by gas turbines for Soldotna seems like a bad choice. All the more so, given that Anchorage Municipal Light & Power offered a power purchase agreement that one HEA Board member reputedly deemed “a pretty good deal.” As one former HEA electrical engineer recently pointed out, it’s unlikely we can ever recover the cost of new Soldotna turbines. With no one but ourselves to sell power to, they will stand idle most of the time and never generate revenue.

Alaska Railbelt Cooperative Transmission and Energy Company (ARCTEC)
HEA and other railbelt utilities continue to work on draft articles of incorporation for this potential confederation aimed at improved collaboration. The stated intent is to improve prospects for dealing with natural gas supply problems, better address transmission issues, and pursue utility scale alternative energy opportunities. According to HEA General Manager Brad Janorschke, utilities hope to come to agreement and file the articles by the end of this month (November). We agree that better collaboration will be needed to effectively meet railbelt energy needs in the coming years. Such efforts are to be commended, assuming that ratepayer interests are being taken into consideration. Unfortunately, as is so often the case, this process is being conducted behind closed doors.

Renewable Double Speak
While all of the HEA Directors say they favor adding more renewable energy sources to our energy mix, General Manager Janorschke has joined with other railbelt utility managers in signing the attached letter to the RCA and legislative leaders complaining that integrating renewable energy into the existing generation scheme is just too difficult. While the letter claims it isn’t a rejection of renewable technologies, it sure comes out reading like one. These utilities have failed to work with each other or potential independent power producers like Fire Island Wind (CIRI) or Kenai Winds to find ways to overcome integration challenges. HEA has committed to spending $180 million (plus) on natural gas generation but only $2-3 million on a single, very controversial, small hydroelectric project and not a dime on technology to balance fluctuations from wind generators. Railbelt utilities predict potentially high costs associated with integrating renewable energy but think nothing of increasing our dependency natural gas, even if we need to import it in liquefied form from outside. Wonder what that’s going to cost?




December HEA/AEEC Meetings
These meetings will all take place in Kenai at the Central Peninsula Offices, 280 Airport Way.

Tuesday, December 7, 2010
2:00 PM -- Operations and Special Projects

Tuesday, December 14, 2010
1:00 PM -- Finance Committee
3:00 PM -- AEEC Board Meeting
5:30 PM -- HEA Board Meeting

Download draft agendas at http://www.homerelectric.com/BoardofDirectorsElections/BoardMeetingInformation/Agendas/tabid/220/Default.aspx. Video conferencing is available in the Homer Offices at 3977 Lake Street -- call either HEA office at 283-5831 (Kenai) or 235-8551 (Homer).

Monday, September 13, 2010

This Week's HEA/AEEC Meetings


These meetings will take place in Kenai at the Central Peninsula Offices, 280 Airport Way.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010
9:00 AM -- Operations and Special Projects
1:00 PM -- Finance Committee
3:30 PM -- AEEC Board Meeting
5:30 PM -- HEA Board Meeting

Download draft agendas at http://www.homerelectric.com/BoardofDirectorsElections/BoardMeetingInformation/Agendas/tabid/220/Default.aspx.
Video conferencing is available in the Homer Offices at 3977 Lake Street.

Next Week's Area Meetings
The proposed new rate structure will be the main focus of the General Manager's presentation.

Anchor Point, 5:30 PM, Monday September 27, Chapman School
Kasilof, 5:30 PM, Tuesday September 28, Tustumena School
Sterling, 5:30 PM, Wednesday September 29, Senior Center
Nikisiki, 5:30 PM, Thursday September 30, Community Center

These meetings are typically a venue for HEA management to express it's point of view in a controlled situation, absent divergent outlooks. Free food and the promise of drawing prizes seem to be uppermost in attending HEA members' minds. Nonetheless, it is an opportunity for you to raise questions and express your own opinions regarding any HEA issue.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

August HEA Meeting Schedule

All meetings will take place in the Board room of the HEA offices in Homer at 3977 Lake Street. Video conferencing is available at the HEA offices in Kenai at 280 Airport Way. Meeting agendas can be found on the HEA website at http://www.homerelectric.com/. Contact Joe Gallagher at jgallagher (email at) homerelectric.com or 907-283-2324 for more information.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010
10:00 AM -- HEA Operations Committee Meeting
12:30 PM -- HEA Finacne Committee Meeting
3:00 PM -- AEEC Board Meeting
5:30 PM -- HEA Board Meeting

Wednesday, August 18, 2010
9:00 AM Final Ratemaking Presentation by Consulting Firm RW Beck

Friday, August 6, 2010

HEA Members Forum Update

HEA Plans Rate Structure Change
Every HEA member has a big stake in this ratemaking process. The outcome will affect the finances of Kenai Peninsula families and businesses for the foreseeable future. Electric rates will increase. They jump two percent this October. They're expected to reach 20-25 cents per kWh by 2014. A new rate structure probably can’t prevent that but HEA members should be wondering just what it might do.

Can it be fair to all classes of ratepayers (residential, commercial, industrial) in all areas?
What will it mean for low wage workers and people on fixed incomes?
Will it promote energy efficiency and conservation?
Can it do anything to stabilize electric rates?
Will it be easy for HEA members to understand?

Attend the Ratemaking Workshop on Wednesday, August 18
Come to the HEA Homer Board Room at 9:00 AM -- video conferencing available at Kenai HEA offices for central peninsula members. This will be the last opportunity for you to learn more about three potential residential rate options under consideration:

1. Raise the present $11.00 per month residential customer charge to around $90.00 (the estimated monthly cost to HEA to provide service) and lower the per kWh energy charge.

2. Raise the $11.00 customer charge to $15.00 and increase the per kWh energy charge.

3. Raise the $11.00 customer charge to $15.00 and require a minimum monthly energy payment based upon 300 kWh of electricity ($36.26). All residential customers would then pay at least $52 per month.

Those options are at the core of this process but only reflect part of the background discussion. For example, there is the issue of basic kWh rate design -- should it be uniform or variable based upon differing levels of consumption, peak vs. off-peak use, summer vs. winter? There are other issues too but no space for discussion here.

Now is the Time to Get Involved
A draft rate plan is expected by the end of this month. The plan will be presented to members at September HEA regional meetings. By then the opportunity for input will be limited -- final rate design will be adopted in October. If you want to help determine how the final plan looks, go to the HEA website (http://www.homerelectric.com/) and read Rate Design: Making It Fair and Promoting Conservation. Try to attend the August 17 HEA Board meeting. Participate in the August 18 ratemaking workshop. Ask questions, explain your priorities, and make suggestions.


BASICS OF ELECTRIC UTILITY RATEMAKING
Electric utility rates include two basic charges, one for recovering “fixed costs” and the other for recovering “variable costs.” For this discussion let’s ignore the taxes and surcharges typically tacked on to your electric bill.

Fixed Costs
These include expenses the utility incurs by just having a customer tied into the system -- wire, poles, buildings and everything needed to provide basic service. These costs have nothing to do with how much or how little energy a customer uses and do not fluctuate.

Variable Costs
These include expenses the utility incurs for equipment, over and above the basics, required by high demand customers and for acquiring the energy it distributes to us. These costs vary depending upon how “big” a service capacity is installed for the customer and how much energy is consumed each month.

Utilities generally consider it good policy to recover fixed costs through fixed charges (the “customer charge”) and variable costs through variable charges (the “energy charge” or “per kWh” charges).

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Rate Design Process

Attached is HEA General Manager Brad Janorschke's announcement of the the rate design process along with a related discussion of some of the things to be considered in designing a sound rate structure. Don't forget about this week's informational workshop -- open to the membership.

Wednesday, July 14, 10:00 AM, Homer HEA offices -- R.W. Beck Rate Making Workshop
For video conferencing to Kenai HEA Offices contact Teresa Gamble at
tgamble ( email@ ) homerelectric.com

Rate Design Article

Saturday, June 12, 2010

HEA Members Forum Update

Rate Creep
On July 1 rates go up .154 of a cent per kWh. According to HEA that's about 97 cents a month for the "average" member. That's better than the 2 percent increase we were expecting -- stay tuned for that one.

Secret Rate Redesign Process
The HEA Board and management have started the process of redesigning how your electric rates are computed. This summer HEA Directors will have "how to" workshops and background documents on the subject. Unfortunately HEAMF requests to participate in the learning process were turned down. In e-mail and telephone contacts with several HEA Directors we urged that the wider membership be informed of this process and provided an overview of what it’s about and how it will unfold. So far management and most Directors don't seem to want ordinary HEA members involved. One thing under review for sure will be the "customer charge." That's the monthly fee all HEA members pay for just being connected to the system. Management has already advised Directors that the present charge is way too low and needs to be increased.

Alternative Energy Smackdown
In his wisdom Governor Parnell vetoed money the Legislature allocated for community natural gas and alternative energy projects for our state. Among these was the $7 million grant for HEA to utilize wind power from the 14.4 MW Kenai Winds project being pursued by APEX energy. Unfortunately for us, at the June 1 special Board meeting HEA General Manager Brad Janorschke told Directors we should give up altogether on trying to integrate wind energy without the $7 million.

Small Hydro Pumpup
On June 1 a special meeting of the HEA Board was sandwiched between the Alaska Electric & Energy Cooperative(AEEC) and HEA Operations Committee meetings to consider Resolution 10-25, allocation of $2 million from the HEA budget for site studies and completion of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) construction permit application process. After a presentation by HEA engineering staff and several minutes of Board discussion the resolution was approved. This came out of the blue with little or no advance notice -- HEA members and organizations with strong interest in the project such as the Kenai Watershed Forum were not made aware of the resolution. If approved, construction cost is estimated at $30 million and the project would produce about 4.5 MW of electricity. Questions remain regarding potential negative impacts to fish and habitat.

Next Week’s HEA Meetings
Tuesday June 15, 2010, Homer HEA Offices (video conferencing available from the Kenai offices).

Closed Board Workshop 12 Noon
Finance Committee Meeting 3:00 PM
Full Board Meeting 5:30 PM

Agendas have not been posted on the HEA website at this writing. Go to the following pages within the next several days to look for meeting and agenda information.
http://www.homerelectric.com/BoardofDirectorsElections/BoardMeetingInformation/Agendas/tabid/220/Default.aspx
http://www.homerelectric.com/BoardofDirectorsElections/MeetingCalendar/tabid/240/Default.aspx

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Kenai Hydro Concerns

HEA Members form participants favor renewable energy projects and encourage our coop to investigate as many potential options as possible. For most of us, however, that does not mean blanket approval of any renewable energy project regardless of its social, economic, or environmental consequences. Many questions were raised about possible negative affect to Kenai River and it's wider watershed from several small hydroelectric projects proposed by HEA known as Kenai Hydro. Preliminary studies confirmed significant problems for all except the Grant Lake project. To HEA's credit, efforts to move forward those projects were dropped. Now, however, HEA has decided to press on with Grant Lake. The Alaska Center for the Environment, Kenai Watershed Forum, and Friends of Cooper Landing contend that the Grant Lake project proffers the same problems as the discontinued projects and should also be abandoned. HEAMF was contacted and asked to circulate the information below and attached.

HEA Management has been silent regarding this project recently, ostensibly lacking funds to proceed. The sudden effort to move forward on a fast rack came as a surprise to many stakeholders. While HEAMF has not taken a pro or con position with regard to Grant Lake, it is important that the issues surrounding it receive serious consideration well in advance any decision to develop. As an HEA member, you deserve to have an opportunity to understand and weigh in on these issues.

"Keep the Kenai River Wild"

Homer Electric Association is moving forward with plans to put a dam on Grant Lake, a tributary of the Kenai River. The plans call for 3.5 miles of new roads and transmission lines, a 10 foot by 120 foot long dam, a 110 foot high surgetank, penstock and powerhouse. Grant Lake would be flooded and the water flow in Grant Creek would be interrupted. The cost of construction is estimated at 27 million dollars. Alaska Center for the Environment believes that the costs of losing fish habitat in one of Alaska’s favorite and most productive local watersheds is too high of a price to pay for the insignificant amount of power which will be generated as a result of this project. Grant Creek supports anadromous fish species including Chinook, sockeye and Coho salmon as well as resident species including rainbow trout and Dolly Varden. The Kenai River system supports 34 species of anadromous and resident fish.

What Can You Do?
Please attend the FERC Scoping Meeting and Environmental Site Review. The meeting will take place in Moose Pass on June 2, at 7 PM at the Moose Pass Community Hall. It is the only opportunity to meet with Federal Energy Regulatory Commission officials. Laws require the Commission to independently evaluate the environmental effects of issuing an original license for the Grant Lake Project as proposed, and to consider reasonable alternatives to the applicant’s proposal. FERC is seeking information about the possible impacts this project could have. These could include impacts to water quality and quantity, fish and wildlife resources, cultural, recreational, aesthetic and economic impacts, land use, geologic, soil and other terrestrial resources.

Sign petition opposing the dam by visiting:

www.ipetitions.com/petition/keep_the_kenai_wild/

Submit scoping comments to FERC: (due July 6th, 2010)

*For more information about the process: http://www.kenaihydro.com/documents/GrantLake_Scoping1.pdf